My Few Minutes with Andy Rooney
Now that Andy Rooney is calling it quits after 1,097 TV essays on 60 Minutes, I thought I’d like to share a little story regarding something Andy said about Dan Rather, me, and liberal bias in the news.
My first book, Bias, came out ten years ago and caused quite a stir. Liberal journalists hated it – and me! The book was an insider’s story about how liberal bias at CBS News, where I had worked for 28 years, and at the rest of the mainstream media actually operated. I was on lots of radio and TV shows talking about the book, but one show I was not on was the Larry King Live on CNN.
Larry, or probably his liberal producer, had no interest in having me on. And since I have no constitutional right to be on Larry’s show, or anyone else’s, I had no problem with the decision. Besides, my book was number one on the New York Times bestseller list without any help from Larry.
But Larry did have a number of other journalists on over time to talk about the news business in general and at some point Larry would inevitably ask what they thought of Bias. One of those journalists was Andy Rooney.
When Larry asked about my book and about liberal bias in the news, Andy was Andy – direct and to the point “There is no question that I – [Andy Rooney] – among others, have a liberal bias,” he said.
I didn’t care about Andy’s liberal bias. He was a commentator and was entitled to his opinions, no matter how liberal. But who were the “among others” who had a liberal bias? That remark had me leaning forward in my chair as I watched the interview.
Then Andy answered the question with this bombshell: “I think Dan [Rather] is transparently liberal. Now he may not like to hear me say that. I always agree with him, too. But I think he should be more careful.”
Wow! Andy Rooney – one of the elder statesmen of television journalism -- had just acknowledged that conservatives had been right all along. He had just outed Dan Rather on national television. Dan Rather was transparently liberal. Even I had never said anything that inflammatory. This was news. Big news. Or so I thought.
The Washington Times, a conservative newspaper, ran the Rooney quote, but no other news organization did. No other newspaper, no television station, no news magazine, no nothing.
Not one media writer found it newsworthy that such a major TV news personality had just said that the anchor of the CBS Evening News was “transparently liberal” – a charge Rather had heard before, many times, but always from conservatives. It always made him fume.
These are the same media writers who had devoted columns to Rather’s haircut or his salary or Katie Couric’s wardrobe. But this – liberal bias at CBS News -- they simply ignored. Liberal bias in the so-called mainstream media was – and still is – a subject the media elites don’t want to take too seriously; if they do, their whole house of cards might come tumbling down.
So the subject went out not with a bang, but with a pathetic whimper.
But before Andy went out, he had one more observation for Larry King, this one aimed right at me. He told Larry that I “just [had] a great knack for being a jerk.” Hey, I’d been called a lot worse, so this shot didn’t register on my give-a-crap meter. I just assumed Andy was covering his rear end, making sure the CBS News brass knew whose side he was on.
It wasn't enough. Not long after Rooney said what he said about Rather, the you-know-what hit the fan at CBS headquarters in New York. A top CBS News executive took Andy to the woodshed for daring to speak the truth. Andy later told me the executive said he was “disloyal” to say those things about Dan being transparently liberal.
But that isn’t the end of the story. Not long after he went on Larry King’s show and got his knuckles rapped, Rooney wrote this in his nationally syndicated column: “As a guest on the Larry King show a few weeks ago, I said some things in answer to his questions, that I would have been better off lying about or avoiding. It was not that the people who objected to what I said necessarily thought I was wrong. They thought I shouldn’t have said it. In my own defense, I told a boss of mine that I thought if all the truth were known by everyone, it would be a better world. He scoffed. I think ‘scoff’ is what he did. I know he rejected the idea."
Translation: As far as Andy Rooney and his bosses at CBS News were concerned, when it came to talking about liberal bias in the news, dishonesty was the best policy. Taking the Fifth and never uttering the words "liberal bias" was an even better policy.
And here's the capper: After mulling it over for a while, Andy concludes right there in his column that his boss was right. "I've thought about it," he wrote, "and in retrospect decided he was right in dismissing what I had to say. Our lives could not survive all the truth about everything."
A while later I wrote Andy a letter. This is part of it:
"It's really pretty simple, Andy: It's not good for news guys to lie. Not even by omission. Not about the news anyway. If you want to lie about how many times a day Jennifer Lopez sneaks into your office and says she can't live without you, no problem.
"But when you start to lie about the serous stuff -- or simply "avoid" the subject -- you cause real problems for honest journalists ...
"The bottom line, Andy, is not just whether a news media that behaves this way can survive. It's whether it even deserves to.