14 Comments
User's avatar
Bob Hadley's avatar

I don't know why only one of the violent insurrectionists was shot. Arguably, it was the duty of the capital police to use all means to protect the capital, the occupants AND themselves, even to the extent of using firearms - assuming they were armed.

James Post's avatar

Restraint on the part of law enforcement. Lethal force used as a last resort.

Would you have preferred more fatalities? I suspect I would have accepted more fatalities to the degree it would have deterred the violent actions. Hard to know if that would have been possible.

Most of the people demonstrating before the break in were peaceful, I do believe. To me, it does not matter what the percentage is, when major violence and damage occur. But it does seem to be relevant to many in the MSM.

The use of the term mostly peaceful was suspended that day, as it did not fit the narrative used to explain damages done by, for example, people destroying monuments to Confederate officials and the like.

Bob Hadley's avatar

"Restraint on the part of law enforcement. Lethal force used as a last resort."

Although Congressmen and their staffs (barely) escaped physically harm, scores of Capital police were beaten, many severely. Obviously, the last resort was warranted.

What if when Neil Gorsuch was being sworn in as a SCOTUS justice, a mob had broken away from a demo declaring that his swearing in was unconstitutional and what if they breached the WH grounds and headed for the WH, many brandishing weapons and combat gear? Under this circumstance, do you really believe that the mob would have been allowed to enter the WH, deface it and head for President Trump, Mr. Gorsuch and GOP heads? Chances are that there'd be a lot more shooting.

"The use of the term mostly peaceful was suspended that day, as it did not fit the narrative used to explain damages done by, for example, people destroying monuments to Confederate officials and the like."

I don't understand what you're saying. Please explain. When, where and who were destroying monuments?

James Post's avatar

You have to have lived on Mars to not know about the efforts to remove Confederate monuments, especially after the George Floyd killing.

You love to play your little childish "prove it" game.

Prove that obviously the last resort was warranted.

And, prove the Representatives barely escaped. I want proof on how many.

We will never know exactly what would have happened about Gorsuch and your what if speculation on stuff that did not happen.

What if Bob Hadley knew something about the violence against Confederate monuments that was prominent in the news a few years ago?

Some examples for you:

JEB Stuart monument in Richmond, defaced. Removed July 2020.

Christopher Columbus statue in Minneapolis, pulled from its pedestal. Hadley technicality, it was not a confederate monument.

Axios, June 7 2020:

Protests against police violence and racism have sharpened the focus of a long-standing debate about the place for and relevance of Confederate-era monuments and iconography.

What's happening: In some cities, monuments have become a hub for demonstrations, while others have been vandalized or toppled by protesters. In some instances, government officials have ordered them to be removed altogether.

Protesters in Richmond on Sunday pulled down a statue of Williams Carter Wickham, a Confederate general during the Civil War.

Having to provide this information to you on things that were prominently in the news a few years ago proves either an intellectual laziness on your part, or a juvenile desire to make me support prominently publicized events.

Hadley playing his prove it game. His pastime.

Bob Hadley's avatar

You're a petulant petunia

I see, you were stooping to whataboutism. I suspected that, but I was giving you the benefit of the doubt. The mob destruction of monuments, while totally unacceptable, is a far cry from badly beating Capital police in a riot - and maybe there was an instance in these )former) cases where the police would be justified to use lethal force. Not only is whataboutism a copout, using it in a false equivalency is stupid or dishonest or both.

While we don't know what would have happened in my hypothetical of Mr.. Gorsuch's swearing-in ceremony at the WH, it's safe to say that the SS would have shot more than one person. They have men, sharpshooters, stationed on the WH roof ready to shoot down any plane invading WH airspace and to mow down any land incursions, even by a single individual. If they allowed armed and angry rioters, hell-bent on disrupting the ceremony and "calling to justice" President Trump and other high-up GOP members entry into the WH they would not have done their job. And YOU would probably applaud them for shooting the violent rioters.

You let your emotions cloud your thinking. Good luck next time bucko.

Tim Holmquist's avatar

I thought the Capital police performed at their very best. They were denied resources and national guard support for hours even though the chief reached out through his channels for support. It was surprising more people were not shot. Babbitt was the first to attempt entry into the chamber through a broken window. I have friends that say she just poked her head through a window which is bull. After watching the video, the officer was justified and stopped the insurgents in their tracks from entering the chamber.

Fair Dinkum Mate's avatar

The Tariff deals are coming thick and fast with so much winning from the President.

What do you think it will take for Trump to totally abandon the idea or at least drastically reverse course?

I've heard some political commentators say "when it starts to hurt big business and the average person in their wallet".

Well that is already happening, and there's no signs of them being dropped anytime soon.

So, will Americans just eat it and smile? After all, what can they do about it? it's what they voted for.

Steve Rogers's avatar

John: The left has moved from celebrating the accomplishments of actual black women of substance to erecting a large statue in New York's Central Park of a generic, overweight, angry black woman with her hands on her hips and attitude in her posture. This is what the progressive left has devolved into. Do they deserve all of the cultural relevance they are losing?

Steve Rogers's avatar

Correcting myself - The statue is actually in Times Square and not Central Park.

Conrad Pogorzelski's avatar

John, you seem to please, all the Trump haters.

John A. Daly's avatar

Conrad, the great thing about having consistent principles, and just being honest with people, is that it doesn't matter which category or sub-category of people likes or dislikes what you're saying on any given day or topic.

I'm a conservative who's concerned about the country. You're a tribalist who's mostly concerned about Trump's feelings, and him getting whatever he wants, regardless of how leftist his agenda is, or what it does to our country. What I say will rarely please you.